MARCH 2026 CLOSING MARKET REPORT ST. AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA

Data curated via “COAST to COAST MLS”
ZIPS 32080 | 32084 | 32086 | 32092 | 32095 | 32033

March Residential Macro Market Averages

New Construction:

  • Average Sale Price = $484.7K

  • Units Sold = 116

  • Range = $228K-$2.175M

Pre-Owned Properties:

  • Average Sale Price = $487.2K ⬇️ (indicative of more competition)

  • Units Sold = 324 ⬆️ (indicative of more favorable pricing)

  • Average Days on Market = 96

  • Range = $112K-$3.1M

  • Notable - 13 properties were $1M++

Vacant Lots/Land/Acreage:

  • Total Lots Sold = 7

  • Average Sale Price = $376K

  • Average Days on Market = 136

  • Sale prices ranged from $13K - $1.4M

  • Two waterfront properties on Vilano Beach/32084 included

Direct Oceanfront:

  • Average Sale Price = $1.087M

  • Units Sold = 7

  • Average Days on Market = 67

  • Range = $420K-$3.1M

Ocean View, Ocean Access, Intracoastal Front, or View:

  • Average Sale Price = $1.119M

  • Units Sold = 4

  • Average Days on Market = 82

  • Range = $386.5K-$3.1M


March Residential Micro Market Averages

per ZIP: All combined Single Family Residence (includes manufactured/mobile), Townhouse, & Condo

Single Family Residence

32080: $675,500

32084: $546,800

32086: $426,700

32092: $550,700

32095: $600,700

32033: $373,000

Townhouse

32080: $376,700

32084: $254,600 (**)

32086: $269,800

32092: $328,900

32095: $299,600

32033: None

Condominium

32080: $429,100 (*)

32084: $277,500 (***)

32086: $221,400

32092: $347,500 (****)

32095: $245,000

32033: None

Anomalies and Explanations where Average Closed Price was Higher

*Notable: Mostly oceanfront or ocean view condos in 32080.

**Notable: A much greater majority of these sales were New Construction WITHOUT garage sales and the category still rose in price most likely due to more favorable HOA monthly fees with townhomes overall.

***Notable: Two sales in this category were (1) intracoastal waterfront Vilano, harbor access to ocean, almost 1700sf, community pool & boat dock, and (2) Intracoastal waterfront, 1200sf, harbor access to intracoastal, community pool & boat dock. Otherwise, the majority of sales average was $238.9K.

****Notable:  A greater majority of these sales were Luxury condos having over 1900s/f to almost 2800 s/f with a garage, and all sales were in World Golf Village.