MAY 2026 CLOSING MARKET REPORT ST. AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA

Data curated via “COAST to COAST MLS”
ZIPS 32080 | 32084 | 32086 | 32092 | 32095 | 32033

May Residential Macro Market Averages

New Construction:

  • Average Sale Price = $489.2K

  • Units Sold = 130

  • Range = $227.1K-$2.147M

  • Notables = 6 Luxury new home builds, once completed, closed well above their original $1M - $2M listing prices

  • Luxury Removed from Equation Avg Sale Price = $445.2K

Pre-Owned Properties:

  • Average Sale Price = $540.8K

  • Units Sold = 334

  • Average Days on Market = 75

  • Range = $125K-$2.69M

  • Notable - 19 properties were $1M-$2M++

  • Luxury Removed from Equation Avg Sale Price = $479.6K

  • Avg Days on Market remained the same = 75

Vacant Lots/Land/Acreage:

  • Total Lots Sold = 12

  • Average Sale Price = $222K

  • Average Days on Market = 79

  • Sale prices ranged from $47K - $630K

Direct Oceanfront:

  • Average Sale Price = $1.109M

  • Units Sold = 10

  • Average Days on Market = 103

  • Range = $450K-$1.48M

Ocean View, Ocean Access, Intracoastal Front, or View:

  • Average Sale Price = $610.8K

  • Units Sold = 14

  • Average Days on Market = 103

  • Range = $169.9K-$998K


May Residential Micro Market Averages

per ZIP: All combined Single Family Residence (includes manufactured/mobile), Townhouse, & Condo

Single Family Residence

32080: $867,300

32084: $525,100

32086: $491,000

32092: $581,600

32095: $562,600

32033: $389,000

Townhouse

32080: $345,000

32084: $317,000 (*)

32086: $265,500

32092: $347,500

32095: $386,400 (**)

32033: None

Condominium

32080: $472,500

32084: $268,400

32086: $255,600

32092: $251,900

32095: $204,700

32033: None

*One 2-story Luxury townhome @ Vilano Beach: 3,000+ s/f, 4 beds, 4 full baths, one garage, elevator, marsh-2-intracoastal unobstructed view sold for $675K. When removed from averages, the townhome average value is $257.3K. The remaining units sold also DID NOT have garages and reason for $60K gap in closed pricing.

**Two 2-story Luxury townhomes @ Palencia: One Includes 2,350 s/f townhome, 550 s/f apartment, 1,070 s/f office space, 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths, 2 half baths, unique midtown European-style village, garage & street parking, $839.5K. One includes a non-village townhome of 3,200+ s/f, 4 beds, 3 baths, 1 powder room, 2.5 garage, $618K. When removed from averages, the townhome average value, (some with/without garage), is $288.6K.